CMS Watch adds some crytical notes to Microsoft's Office Live Workspace offering:
... Not enough free diskspace ... the service is a companion (hence the term Software + Services). They seem to like the integrationpoint with Office and Outlook.
They are fully right in stating that it is not 100% comparable to Zoho / Google Apps, etc. And that's right. Companies who will make use of this service do this to share information with others, maybe mainly those outside their company. This means they will certianly not put all of their documents 'in the cloud' but only those that need to be shared in for example collaborative projects with business partners. This seems like a good differentiator to me ...
... Microsoft has announced Office Live Workspace (OLW) and its like a SaaS version of SharePoint Light, only perhaps lighter than one might expect.
Office is taking a beating in the feisty SaaS sector, where Zoho, Google Apps and others are currently vying for marketshare. Even Adobe has recently announced it would be acquiring the parent company of Buzzword, which provides Office-esque capabilities seamlessly between the Web and (eww!) non-Web worlds. ...
... Rather than a replacement, think companion.
The Office Live Workspace aims to replicate a portion of SharePoint’s collaboration and storage facilities, in a Web-based portal. The quick and dirty summary is that it gives Microsoft Live users a free (watch that word) place to store, share and collaborate on documents. The kick-off storage limit is reported at a measly 250 MB — which MS claims is good enough to “store 1000+ Microsoft Office documents in one place.”
CMSWire speaks to a range of industry professionals and organizations focused on content management issues. Learn more.
Yeah right. We’re expecting some pretty early frustration. 2 GB isn’t even good enough for email these days. We have to ask, just what are they thinking?
Anyhow, aside from skimping on storage, the new offer does have some potential. Office champs will be able to upload, download, view, edit (offline) and comment on (online) documents.
Now, here’s what you can’t do: You can’t create new documents, or edit existing ones directly. You can’t create a wiki. You can’t create a blog. You can’t create custom lists. You can’t run online discussions or presentations.
Remember, the service is a companion. To participate, you’ll still need MS Office installed locally.
With this in mind, there are a few other Office integration points. You’ll be able to tie-in with Outlook by synchronizing contacts, tasks and event lists. This is not ground breaking, but could prove useful to some.
From our seat, this comes off like a classic case of defending marketshare — a.k.a., a stop-gap — rather than taking the offensive tack. And really, this doesn’t address the Google Apps/Zoho/Adobe threats at all; it only assumes that an enterprise-based Word or Excel user really just dislikes the idea of transferring documents back and forth via email or other storage media — to quote the OLW website, “No more flash drives.” ...
Source: SharePoint Light is Live and SaaSy but Lacks Depth